Nursery admission: HC refuses interim stay on order scrapping points system
The court said the issue requires detailed consideration and so it will hear the interim application for stay along with the main appeal on Tuesday
The court also questioned whether there is ‘any material available which shows that it is applicable to this academic year’. Photo: HT New Delhi: The Delhi high court on Monday refused to pass an interim order staying its single judge bench verdict quashing the points system for nursery admission brought in by the Lieutenant Governor (LG) for private unaided schools in New Delhi. A bench of chief justice G. Rohini and justice R.S. Endlaw said the issue requires detailed consideration, so it will hear the interim application for stay against the operation of its single judge order along with the main appeal on Tuesday. “We will not stay the order today. It is a matter which requires consideration, so we will hear it in detail tomorrow,” it said. The court also questioned whether there is “any material available which shows that it is applicable to this academic year”. Replying to the query, senior advocate P.P. Malhotra, appearing for the Delhi government’s directorate of education, said, “It has implication for this year.” The single judge had passed the order on 28 November, this year while disposing of two petitions by a committee and a forum representing the private schools which had challenged the LG’s 18 December 2013 and 27 December 2013 notifications by which the points system was introduced. Contending that the order passed by the single judge is “totally wrong”, “erroneous” and “against the law”, the Delhi government’s counsel said that the verdict has not appreciated the correct legal position and scheme of Article 21 (Protection of Life and Personal Liberty) and Article 21-A (Right to Education) of the Constitution besides laying undue emphasis on the right of schools. “The judge erred to hold that if parents are given freedom to choose school, the good schools would attract more students and would expand and not-so-good schools would lose students,” the petition said. It contended that there cannot be any discrimination, question of autonomy in the matter of admitting children around three years of age in nursery. “The judge has failed to consider that education is a paramount consideration for the welfare of the society and in this, there are several participants... Quash and set aside the impugned judgement dated 28 November with all consequential benefits and reliefs,” the government had pleaded to the court.
Read more at: http://www.livemint.com/Politics/DY8I5ses6NxZsIu0WHLE4I/Nursery-admission-HC-refuses-interim-stay-on-order-scrappin.html?utm_source=copy
The court also questioned whether there is ‘any material available which shows that it is applicable to this academic year’. Photo: HT New Delhi: The Delhi high court on Monday refused to pass an interim order staying its single judge bench verdict quashing the points system for nursery admission brought in by the Lieutenant Governor (LG) for private unaided schools in New Delhi. A bench of chief justice G. Rohini and justice R.S. Endlaw said the issue requires detailed consideration, so it will hear the interim application for stay against the operation of its single judge order along with the main appeal on Tuesday. “We will not stay the order today. It is a matter which requires consideration, so we will hear it in detail tomorrow,” it said. The court also questioned whether there is “any material available which shows that it is applicable to this academic year”. Replying to the query, senior advocate P.P. Malhotra, appearing for the Delhi government’s directorate of education, said, “It has implication for this year.” The single judge had passed the order on 28 November, this year while disposing of two petitions by a committee and a forum representing the private schools which had challenged the LG’s 18 December 2013 and 27 December 2013 notifications by which the points system was introduced. Contending that the order passed by the single judge is “totally wrong”, “erroneous” and “against the law”, the Delhi government’s counsel said that the verdict has not appreciated the correct legal position and scheme of Article 21 (Protection of Life and Personal Liberty) and Article 21-A (Right to Education) of the Constitution besides laying undue emphasis on the right of schools. “The judge erred to hold that if parents are given freedom to choose school, the good schools would attract more students and would expand and not-so-good schools would lose students,” the petition said. It contended that there cannot be any discrimination, question of autonomy in the matter of admitting children around three years of age in nursery. “The judge has failed to consider that education is a paramount consideration for the welfare of the society and in this, there are several participants... Quash and set aside the impugned judgement dated 28 November with all consequential benefits and reliefs,” the government had pleaded to the court.
Read more at: http://www.livemint.com/Politics/DY8I5ses6NxZsIu0WHLE4I/Nursery-admission-HC-refuses-interim-stay-on-order-scrappin.html?utm_source=copy
